Puyol Or Cannavaro

[EKBATAN]

My SIGNATURE

[babak_australia]

ok well in that case I guess you just dont have very good football knowledge, or at least IMO anyways arent you the guy who always brings up analysts as a way of proving which players/teams are better since they are experts? Because im pretty sure 90-95% of analysts would say Cannavaro over Puyol hands down...anyways its ok to disagree.

im not in competition with you man, im 24 years old and have loved football since the first time i wathed it so i feel i have some knowledge of the game. I think Barca had a great season and won both the CL and the league, that is my major reason for thinking he is the best rite now.

There brother is my facts for deciding he is the best.

Factors that work against me are that Juve had less goals against but taking it all in, i decided on Puyol. Is that ok??

[Milad-69]

Yeah and these 'good' games made him almost win the golden ball huh? and babak what the hell are you talking about MUCH better? you know what I expected these comments from you haters, I dont even know why I waste my time discussing with some of you anymore.

Loool I didnt say Cannavaro is a BAD defender....
He truely is one of the worldz best...but i look at Puyol as a leader...
its my oppinion...i didnt enforce it on anybody amir jan..

[Milad-69]

By the way if Cannavaro was the SECOND best defender in the world cup may I ask you who you thought was the first? Anyways never forget :

Loool man cool down...we aint trying to take ur life away..this is a discussion on who would you prefer...
You think cannavaro
we think Puyol...
thats it...
no need to get on the offensive aziz
take a deep breath...
Cannavaro is still here...and he is a GREAT defender...But for ME i would choose a defender that can bring his teamz moralz up...more than a one man defence(Canavaro)

[babak_australia]

Loool man cool down...we aint trying to take ur life away..this is a discussion on who would you prefer...
You think cannavaro
we think Puyol...
thats it...
no need to get on the offensive aziz
take a deep breath...
Cannavaro is still here...and he is a GREAT defender...But for ME i would choose a defender that can bring his teamz moralz up...more than a one man defence(Canavaro)

Well spoken man.

[ardi11]

cannavaro

[Amir H F]

Loool man cool down...we aint trying to take ur life away..this is a discussion on who would you prefer...
You think cannavaro
we think Puyol...
thats it...
no need to get on the offensive aziz
take a deep breath...
Cannavaro is still here...and he is a GREAT defender...But for ME i would choose a defender that can bring his teamz moralz up...more than a one man defence(Canavaro)

lol I asked you who you thought was the first best defender in the world cup! who said I got offensive? I simply put a picture of one of the defenders whom we are debating about and a big HONOR which he recently earned...what does have to do with my life? deep breath? Just stating my opinion and as long as you dont say he is MUCH better or is CLEARLY better than Cannavaro I can accept the fact that your not biased and if anyone needs to cool down its you 'gangsta'.

[Amir H F]

im not in competition with you man, im 24 years old and have loved football since the first time i wathed it so i feel i have some knowledge of the game. I think Barca had a great season and won both the CL and the league, that is my major reason for thinking he is the best rite now.
There brother is my facts for deciding he is the best.
Factors that work against me are that Juve had less goals against but taking it all in, i decided on Puyol. Is that ok??

Bro were not in competition we are here to discuss football with our hamvatans and im sorry if you think my posts are aggressive and you get offended at times...i'll try to be careful next time, but the ONLY reason I brought this up was because you straight up come out and say Puyol is MUCH better as if we are comparing Sattar Zareh to Roberto Carlos for example, but then when you go into detail you make it close but you choose Puyol...which is fine of course but the first post you made was just ridiculous and I found it to be biased, just pointing out my opinion on your observasion...is that ok with you? anyways you said Champions league was your decisive factor, well the WORLD CUP was mine...anyways moving on.

[Milad-69]

lol I asked you who you thought was the first best defender in the world cup! who said I got offensive? I simply put a picture of one of the defenders whom we are debating about and a big HONOR which he recently earned...what does have to do with my life? deep breath? Just stating my opinion and as long as you dont say he is MUCH better or is CLEARLY better than Cannavaro I can accept the fact that your not biased and if anyone needs to cool down its you 'gangsta'.

Yea but it sounded like i was talking shit abt ur family or something(Which i am not)...



PS: Puyol is DA SHIT!...
Real and Cannavaro Cant Spit!

Na Na just messing wit ya aziz

[Amir H F]

Yea but it sounded like i was talking shit abt ur family or something(Which i am not)...
PS: Puyol is DA SHIT!...
Real and Cannavaro Cant Spit!
Na Na just messing wit ya aziz

ok cool now that we settled that, who was the best defender in the world cup ...im dying to know over here because only one man comes to my mind.

[186forever]

well most of you know that I support Spain and Hate Italy. But I don t think my answer will be bais since many of others are also picking puyol. I don t agree that Puyol is much better, but he definatly has the edge. Before the worldcup, Canavaro's name would not be among the top 5, but definatly top 10. Puyol has been named among the best 5 defenders since 2002-2003. He has been Spain's Best defender for years now. He let the Defendse of Barcelona for a whole season, not just a tournoment. They won La Liga and Champions League....Of course Canavaro let Italy to victory also. But I think that Puyol is a bit more aggressive, much better tackles, and consistancy. So I pick Puyol

he has even better raitings in winning eleven

[babak_australia]

Bro were not in competition we are here to discuss football with our hamvatans and im sorry if you think my posts are aggressive and you get offended at times...i'll try to be careful next time, but the ONLY reason I brought this up was because you straight up come out and say Puyol is MUCH better as if we are comparing Sattar Zareh to Roberto Carlos for example, but then when you go into detail you make it close but you choose Puyol...which is fine of course but the first post you made was just ridiculous and I found it to be biased, just pointing out my opinion on your observasion...is that ok with you? anyways you said Champions league was your decisive factor, well the WORLD CUP was mine...anyways moving on.

All good bro, i love our arguements. I donmt take them serious and im sure u dont. Its good to have someone to debate with.

Anyway my fist post was with passion but as u can see i explained my reasoning for chosing Puyol as i always aim to do.

Keep up the good work.

P.S I sent u a rep but i accidently pressed enter and it went thru unfinished.

[Amir H F]

All good bro, i love our arguements. I donmt take them serious and im sure u dont. Its good to have someone to debate with.
Anyway my fist post was with passion but as u can see i explained my reasoning for chosing Puyol as i always aim to do.
Keep up the good work.
P.S I sent u a rep but i accidently pressed enter and it went thru unfinished.

Thanks bro your certainly one of my favorite members in discussion as well, and as you mentioned our arguments only get heated because we have so much passion for our team! and oddly enough they are all the opposite usually...you like Arsenal, Henry, France, Barca and I like Milan, Man. Utd, Robinho, Italy, Madrid , anyways Cannavaro still has my vote

[186forever]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAYLa-cVXjQ

Don t F...with Puyol

[babak_australia]

Thanks bro your certainly one of my favorite members in discussion as well, and as you mentioned our arguments only get heated because we have so much passion for our team! and oddly enough they are all the opposite usually...you like Arsenal, Henry, France, Barca and I like Milan, Man. Utd, Robinho, Italy, Madrid , anyways Cannavaro still has my vote

Apart from my team being holland and not france you are rite bro our teams are the fiercest of rivals and seeing as out love for football is soo strong it refelcts on our discussions.

Thats awesome. Keep up the good work