Best Left Back?

[PersianMadrid7]

For someone that says R.Carlos is not a legend, I don't think it's necessary to continue arguing with him.

[milad]

here is a memory of WC90.


watch the last 30 seconds. can you find a worse judgement than this?!?

whats this got to do with the greatest leftback of all time vote?

[VivaItalia]

here is the champion's compilation, enjoy...

[VivaItalia]

here is a memory of WC90.


watch the last 30 seconds. can you find a worse judgement than this?!?

[VivaItalia]

whats with the cheap shot?

you are not logical man... your unusual love for italy is blinding any sense of logic that you have. you say "maldini is a legend, carlos is just a good defender", hows that even logical? then you attack me by saying im 16 which is supposed to mean IM not logical.

When Maldini was selected the best LB for several years, your parrent's weren't even sure if they wanna have a kid named Milad or not.

That's why I say, don't ask 16 year old kids. You guys don't even remember how Maldini played.

and for your information, Maldini was selected in many many century selections by magazines. I'm not saying that Carlos is inferior to Maldini, No, but Maldini is a legend. Carlos is not. Legends usually wear Captain's armband for a long time, Carlos never did! Maldini is a natural leader, Carlos never was!

You see the difference now?

[Amin_]

This is a tough one, but I gotta go with Maldini.

[ShirFarhad]

Maldini was a much better defender but I have always been a fan of Roberto Carlos so no player will get a vote over him

[milad]

With all due respect, this is one of silly poll.

Maldini is a legend, Carlos is just a good defender. That's the difference. Ask the people who know soccer, not a bunch of 16 year old Brazilian fans (uhum uhum, Milad kind!)

whats with the cheap shot?

you are not logical man... your unusual love for italy is blinding any sense of logic that you have. you say "maldini is a legend, carlos is just a good defender", hows that even logical? then you attack me by saying im 16 which is supposed to mean IM not logical.

[Milad-69]

With all due respect, this is one of silly poll.

Maldini is a legend, Carlos is just a good defender. That's the difference. Ask the people who know soccer, not a bunch of 16 year old Brazilian fans (uhum uhum, Milad kind!)

Are You Refering to me aziz??! lool

[VivaItalia]

With all due respect, this is one of silly poll.

Maldini is a legend, Carlos is just a good defender. That's the difference. Ask the people who know soccer, not a bunch of 16 year old Brazilian fans (uhum uhum, Milad kind!)

[PersianMadrid7]

you are rite man but u miss my point, The ball should never have gone for a corner. Carlos could have kicked out easily but he chipped it up to kick it further and he mis-chipped it and it went out for a corner. Totally un-necessary.
I also think the guy fluked a few free kick and that is why he is loved more.
There is at least 10-15 ppl that have been better then him at free kicks.

name one of them that's a left back.

[babak_australia]

corners happen. if you get scored off a corner you cant blame the guy who made the corner happen.

you are rite man but u miss my point, The ball should never have gone for a corner. Carlos could have kicked out easily but he chipped it up to kick it further and he mis-chipped it and it went out for a corner. Totally un-necessary.

I also think the guy fluked a few free kick and that is why he is loved more.

There is at least 10-15 ppl that have been better then him at free kicks.

[milad]

Bro, Carlos had no reason to try to do a scissor kick in defence but he did and the ball went for a corner and Zidane scored his first goal from that corner.
The second goal Zidane scored went thru Carlos' legs when he had front post.
I may be harsh or not but imo that is two goals he cost them.
He was pure entertainment and nothing more. Im glad he never played for my team to be honest.

corners happen. if you get scored off a corner you cant blame the guy who made the corner happen.

[Ali]

Faraz U made it tooo hard-U gave us to many choices!

[babak_australia]

agree with everything...but i dont think carlos was to blame for either of the goals vs france in 98

Bro, Carlos had no reason to try to do a scissor kick in defence but he did and the ball went for a corner and Zidane scored his first goal from that corner.
The second goal Zidane scored went thru Carlos' legs when he had front post.

I may be harsh or not but imo that is two goals he cost them.

He was pure entertainment and nothing more. Im glad he never played for my team to be honest.