What if you had only two options to choose..

[Essi]

I thought, both for fun and out of pure curiosity, to create a controversial poll that most likely won't even happen, but it would be fun to see both the answers and the reactions here. Please keep it clean.

Imagine if you had the mandate to make a decision and there were only two choices. To have GN as head coach during WC2006, or CQ. Who would you have chosen? Again, this is just for fun and no ifs and buts. Just these two choises.

[IranPowned]

CQ duh, is that even a question haha? At least CQ can build, AG can only destroy.

[Keano]

Without a shadow of a doubt CQ. I would take CQ any given day over GN and the likes of him. During Queiroz we had a defense that was so organized and inpenetrable for most of our Asian counterparts and even many worldclass teams, while we often lacked offensive games and high scoring wins. Whereas under GN's helm, we have been experiencing one of TM's worst defense, while sucking at scoring as well. So absolutely a lose-lose case with GN

[a_m]

This is CQ team , he built it , AG has not added a single thing,,

2018 WC Russia CQ had built a master team ,
khalizadeh and kanani were available then , but CQ deemed them huge liability both for team chemistry and on the field mistakes ,,, now 8 years later only thing that AG did was add these two clowns back to the team ….

that makes you think when they were in their prime and they weren’t good enough, make them better 8 years later ?!?!?

CQ had discipline, he had class , he had structure, no one was above him and no one was above the team , he held players accountable, he was a master Defensive expert, and he had a plan for every single game
,
yes his tactics were too defensive, but he is wayyyyyy better than AG…

[a_m]

I thought, both for fun and out of pure curiosity, to create a controversial poll that most likely won't even happen, but it would be fun to see both the answers and the reactions here. Please keep it clean.

Imagine if you had the mandate to make a decision and there were only two choices. To have GN as head coach during WC2006, or CQ. Who would you have chosen? Again, this is just for fun and no ifs and buts. Just these two choises.

Why is there something in the works ???
I hope so !!

tell me taj contacted him

[persiangodfather]

in my opinion CQ only screwed up 1 game and that was the one against USA cuz he didnt manage that game well and it can be said in his defense he was added last minute to the team. He never should have got fired in the first place then we would have beat or ties USA

[Salar]

Anybody over GN. Some of you will argue with me but I would call CQ tomorrow to offer him the job.

[The]

Ghalenoi.
We know CQ and his ceiling (group stage exit). I'd take basically anyone over CQ because of the fact that he had three chances already.

GN might have a horseshoe up his ass and make it out of the group. He probably won't, but we know that CQ certainly won't.

[persian-eagle-13]

Bring back CQ, Make Team Melli Great Again (MTMGA)

[mehdi13]

Ghalenoi.
We know CQ and his ceiling (group stage exit). I'd take basically anyone over CQ because of the fact that he had three chances already.

GN might have a horseshoe up his ass and make it out of the group. He probably won't, but we know that CQ certainly won't.

Ghalenoei won’t make it out of the group. He will finish with zero points. Idk why you posted this. Even the ones who were excited about the “General”’s arrival don’t think this way anymore. 0% chance.

[The]

Ghalenoei won’t make it out of the group. He will finish with zero points. Idk why you posted this. Even the ones who were excited about the “General”’s arrival don’t think this way anymore. 0% chance.

Very likely that he won't get a single point, but still I would take him or anyone (even an Azadegan league manager) over CQ for the simple fact that we know CQ can't get us out of the group.

I don't even think CQ is particularly bad, but he had three chances and got the same result every time. I could be tactics, luck, vibe ,etc... whatever it is we know it doesn't work. At least GN, Khatibi, Enayati, etc... have the benefit of zero sample size.

We cannot keep living in the past. We have to try new things.

[persian-eagle-13]

Ghalenoei won’t make it out of the group. He will finish with zero points. Idk why you posted this. Even the ones who were excited about the “General”’s arrival don’t think this way anymore. 0% chance.

He wants to go to the WC at all cost even if it means losing all the games. For him its personal.

[perspolis#1]

We cannot keep living in the past. We have to try new things.

Please forward this line to Ghalenoei

[Keshwardoost]

I thought, both for fun and out of pure curiosity, to create a controversial poll that most likely won't even happen, but it would be fun to see both the answers and the reactions here. Please keep it clean.

Imagine if you had the mandate to make a decision and there were only two choices. To have GN as head coach during WC2006, or CQ. Who would you have chosen? Again, this is just for fun and no ifs and buts. Just these two choises.

Im happy with GN so far, so GN for WC, backup CQ
CAN WE HAVE THEM BOTH?

[IRAN_TILL_I_DIE]

Looking at potential seeding with teams already qualified we could get (best case)

Canada
iran
South Africa
New Zealand