Referee mistakes PGL 2014-2105!

[rugs]

Re: Referee mistakes PGL 2014-2105!

you got a good point ! i think he was trying for the little nudge on the back! navad should be good this weekend!!

Navad is good every week!

[Leopard]

I would not worry anymore about referees mistakes because they average out. IPL teams play 32 games and statistically speaking 30 would be a good number.

By the way elsewhere heidari said the ball touched his fingernail. that means finger since the ball's surface is not as a razor blade.

Sometimes referees make mistake and we saw that wheh they helped Brazil in the opening match and then guess what brazil was knocked out.

The SS team we saw yesterday did not deserve tie or victory so even without that penalty the score would have been 2-1 .

Anyway after 32 games the mistakes get averaged out and the best team wins. so the mini trophies do not mean much because of the fewer games and some mistakes of referees, but for IPL championship you have to play as a champion and GN's team was not even close. So they have to work harder. In plast week's game SS did not do well in spite a victory. This is good lesson for GN and Daei to think why the Sepahan coach is so good and he manages to create an offensive team no matter who leaves and who comes.

We have to give Sepahan coach credit and of course don't forget navidkia. He is a brilliant guy.

[Amin_]

I have watched the scene again for many times and to me it looks like as if the ball first hits KB's arm and then Heydari's hand. It could have also easily been a fk for Esteghlal. It was a very harsh call imo.


And that midget KB is so small that if a normal man puts up his arm even 2 inches, his hand will touch his (KB's) armpit already lol Not that Heydari is a giant or anything, but still

[shahname]

[shahname]

Yet another statement from a fellow referee that calls it a mistake.

کارشناس داوری فوتبال گفت: پنالتی که به سود سپاهان در دیدار با استقلال گرفته شد به نظرم درست نبود.
رضا غیاثی در گفت*وگو با خبرنگار ورزشی خبرگزاری فارس، در مورد عملکرد تیم داوری دیدار سپاهان و استقلال اظهار داشت: قبل از اینکه در مورد عملکرد داوری بخواهم صحبت کنم باید بگویم فغانی در قضاوت*هایش به پختگی خوبی رسیده است. او پیش از آغاز فصل در جمع داوران در مورد تجربیاتش در جام جهانی برای داوران صحبت کرد. او گفت که در جام جهانی آموزش**هایی که به ما دادند این بود که داور باید خوددار باشد و از حرکت*های تند پیشگیری کند.

وی ادامه داد: در این بازی هم دیدم که او با حوصله بسیار زیادی بازی را اداره می*کرد و کاملا با فغانی گذشته فرق کرده بود.

کارشناس داوری فوتبال در مورد صحنه پنالتی سپاهان گفت: در این مورد من نه هند دیدم نه خطا؛ اگر فغانی فکر کره است که مدافع استقلال روی بازیکن سپاهان دست گذاشته است خیلی سختگیرانه سوت زده است.

غیاثی عنوان کرد: در سایر موارد او و کمک*هایش بسیار مسلط بودند. در مورد اخراج شجاع خلیل*زاده هم فغانی به درستی عمل کرد.

کارشناس داوری با اشاره گل سوم استقلال گفت: در این صحنه کمک داور بازی بسیار خوب عمل کرد و در مورد آفساید به دقت عمل کرد.

[rugs]

in yaru ke aslan to bagh nist....

He is saying that Heydari didn't push KB and makes no mention of the handball. I question this guy's eye sight.

[rugs]

Yet another statement from a fellow referee that calls it a mistake.

کارشناس داوری فوتبال گفت: پنالتی که به سود سپاهان در دیدار با استقلال گرفته شد به نظرم درست نبود.
رضا غیاثی در گفت*وگو با خبرنگار ورزشی خبرگزاری فارس، در مورد عملکرد تیم داوری دیدار سپاهان و استقلال اظهار داشت: قبل از اینکه در مورد عملکرد داوری بخواهم صحبت کنم باید بگویم فغانی در قضاوت*هایش به پختگی خوبی رسیده است. او پیش از آغاز فصل در جمع داوران در مورد تجربیاتش در جام جهانی برای داوران صحبت کرد. او گفت که در جام جهانی آموزش**هایی که به ما دادند این بود که داور باید خوددار باشد و از حرکت*های تند پیشگیری کند.

وی ادامه داد: در این بازی هم دیدم که او با حوصله بسیار زیادی بازی را اداره می*کرد و کاملا با فغانی گذشته فرق کرده بود.

کارشناس داوری فوتبال در مورد صحنه پنالتی سپاهان گفت: در این مورد من نه هند دیدم نه خطا؛ اگر فغانی فکر کره است که مدافع استقلال روی بازیکن سپاهان دست گذاشته است خیلی سختگیرانه سوت زده است.

غیاثی عنوان کرد: در سایر موارد او و کمک*هایش بسیار مسلط بودند. در مورد اخراج شجاع خلیل*زاده هم فغانی به درستی عمل کرد.

کارشناس داوری با اشاره گل سوم استقلال گفت: در این صحنه کمک داور بازی بسیار خوب عمل کرد و در مورد آفساید به دقت عمل کرد.

Ghiyasi is not a credible person. He rarely gets invited on Navad and when he does it is almost out of pity.

He is apparently blind as well. He says that he didn't see a handball but yet fails to explain how the ball bounced directly back the way it came.

I would wait for Navad when someone with more credibility and is actually involved in football comments.

It may well be the case that some say it wasn't, but these guys you posted are just Ali Asghars of Iranian football.

[unique football]

i just saw the clip posted and it shows in 20x slow motion and it did not hit any part of kb's hand arm or elbow i will copy paste the link once i get it , if i copy paste from facebook it doesnt open , any who see's this clip and still says it touches KB im sorry buy you need to consult a doctor.

[unique football]

i could not find a direct link but here this a fanpage of sepahan and click on it scroll down you would see the video in super slow motion , im just waiting for some1 to say sepahanis edited the film
link: https://www.facebook.com/sepahan.tza?fref=ts

[saadat_abad]

i could not find a direct link but here this a fanpage of sepahan and click on it scroll down you would see the video in super slow motion , im just waiting for some1 to say sepahanis edited the film
link: https://www.facebook.com/sepahan.tza?fref=ts

dude in that slo mo video u can perfectly see how it hits kbs hand first...

[kia]

IR media & its "specialists":
1st goal was not a PK. 2nd goal was offside & the ref got paid on the 3rd goal. There were also 3 pks not called for Esteghlal.

[rugs]

dude in that slo mo video u can perfectly see how it hits kbs hand first...

His hand? I just watched it, it hits his chest then Heydari punches it. What part of the hand are you seeing it hit?

[saadat_abad]

His hand? I just watched it, it hits his chest then Heydari punches it. What part of the hand are you seeing it hit?

chest? yeah it somewhat hit his side but u can perfectly see it hit right below his elbow then hit heydaris hand

[unique football]

dude in that slo mo video u can perfectly see how it hits kbs hand first...

i think you are watching something else , clearly look at his hand and you will notice it didint , ama be shoma begim sefide migid na sias
first you say hand then say arm make up ur mind .

[saadat_abad]

i think you are watching something else , clearly look at his hand and you will notice it didint , ama be shoma begim sefide migid na sias
first you say hand then say arm make up ur mind .

lol. seeing the slo motion it is clear the ball hits kb's elbow. if you dont believe just wait untill navad