Printable View
We definitely have the best SQUAD in Asia. We'll have to wait and see about the "team" part because a lot of that comes down to preparation,Quote:
Originally Posted by ghermez agha
coordination, and tactics.
Quote:
Originally Posted by St_Mark
Hope the game against TM Omid happens. This is the first good/logical move I've seen in at least two months. This would be a good game for both teams.
Quote:
Originally Posted by O-ZoNe
If Heidari is not going to be ready for the first game , it's huge risk to take him.
For what it was reported he may be ready for the third game .
Quote:
ضعيت پاي خسرو هر چند روز به روز بهتر مي شود اما ترميم آن زمانبر است. عضله دوقلوي اين بازيكن آسيب ديده و دردي قديمي به حساب مي آيد.
از آنجا كه حيدري بعد از هر مصدوميت سريع بازگشته و بازي كرده، عضله پايش ضعيف شده است. خسرو در بهترين حالت از 5 روز ديگر تمريناتش را آغاز مي كند و تازه از روز بعد از بازي با بحرين در اولين مسابقه گروهي، تمرينات گروهي اش را آغاز مي كند.
او در بهترين حالت به بازي با امارات در مرحله گروهي مي رسد، يعني ديدار با بحرين و قطر را صددرصد غايب است. خسرو به احتمال فراوان مسافر استراليا خواهد بود.
با مصدوميت اين بازيكن، نگراني هاي كروش تشديد شده است. به احتمال زياد مربي پرتغالي مجبور مي شود رامين رضاييان مدافع راه آهن را هم همراه خود ببرد. او در اردوي آفريقا در دفاع راست خوب كار كرد و توانست با وريا غفوري رقابت كند
You continuously keep missing the point. He should have planned for it before the WC, not after. And the blame for long drawn out process of negotiations goes to both IFF and CQ. How soon we forget that CQ wasn't in Iran for most of that period and it was always IFF that was waiting for a response for weeks at a time.Quote:
Originally Posted by BacheLot
Who said it was the other way around?! My point was that even that game wasn't requested by CQ and IFF had no issues arranging it, which I'm glad you're finally agreeing with.Quote:
Originally Posted by BacheLot
Whoopi doo, they got one more point in 2010 from a super easy group than they did in 2014 from one of the two toughest groups of the WC which included the world's best team... 3rd placed team, a quarter finalist and a round of 16 participant from 2010. You're comparing their performance in this group to 2010 where the best team in their group was a quarter-final participant from 2006 and two pretty weak teams?!Quote:
Originally Posted by BacheLot
The saddest part is that despite being drawn in such an easy group in 2010 and coming off their best WC showing post Eusebio in 2006 and all that momentum, they did not manage to score a single goal against any opponent other than North Korea. And after that their Euro qualifying campaign was off to a disastrous start. You think this is just my opinion and I wrote a letter to the FPF and asked them to sack CQ?! :rolleyes:
Sure, let's assume that playing one good half against Argentina, getting 1 point in the group stage and being eliminated was Iran's greatest football achievement of all time. The WC is over my friend. We're going to be dwelling in that (even if it was a great achievement) for the next 10, 20 years? That' behind us now and we have the Asian Cup ahead, much like Portugal had the Euro qualifying ahead of it after the 2010 WC.Quote:
Originally Posted by BacheLot
I have no problem judging people on the merit of their performance. I just haven't seen anything since the WC to conclude that we have built on that foundation with arguably the best and strongest squad in Asia. Quite the contrary, everything points to us going backward and having a very poor showing at the Asian Cup. And believe me when I say nothing would make me happier than to be wrong in this case. The fact is that we haven't even been tested enough against semi quality sides, let alone quality sides, to be able to evaluate TM's current shape.
This is just blah blah blah. Iran came off a 4% growth in the 3rd quarter. The Portugal and S. Africa camps weren't cheap and TM Omid has planned three camps and some decent friendlies in just a week. So IFF, money and sanctions are NOT the issue. But let's assume they were a problem, just for the sake of argument. If that was the case, would it not have made more sense not to spend the money for those two camps to play the reserve and youth teams of club teams and instead have the camps in Tehran or Kish and play the main squads of a couple of IPL teams, particularly in case of S. Africa?Quote:
Originally Posted by BacheLot
You really think playing the reserve team of a relegation zone S. African team was better preparation and test for TM than playing an IPL team?! Would it not have made more sense to have the camps in Iran so our legionnaires could join the camp and get assimilated into the team as soon as they arrived back in Iran, instead of throwing away another 4-5 precious days of training so close to the Asian Cup?!
You guys make very little sense with your arguments. On the one side you blame everything on lack of money and say other national teams don't want to play us, and on the other side you fully support spending all that money to fly the team to another continent just to do some stretches and play shittier teams than we could have played at home. Which one is it? If the money's lacking, then at least agree that it should be spent more wisely. :whatta:
Look, we all want what's best for TM. The difference between you and I is that my support for TM is unconditional, but that support for individual players, TM cadre or the IFF is NOT. You also support TM unconditionally which is GREAT, but you have the same type of unconditional support for individual coaches and players. In your mind CQ hasn't done anything wrong because he can't do anything wrong and even if he did you would still support him because he, in your mind has a great resume.
To me TM is bigger than individuals - it belongs to and represents the whole nation. In that sense, its interests come above everyone and anyone else and as long as someone can achieve the type of greatness that TM is capable of, I don't really pay attention to their resume past the 1st 3-6 months of their assignment. From there on, my support is just based on their planning and achievement with TM.
His contract was scheduled to end after the Bosnia game. Would any coach plan for a tournament that is beyond his contract?:) Come on bro:)Quote:
Originally Posted by Bi-honar
Not really true. CQ made it very clear that he wanted to re-sign as soon as the world cup ended. It was IFF that kept dragging out the process and Kaffshian even admitted to it the day they finally offered him a contract. When asked by journalists when they expected a response, he said "We've given Queiroz the run-around for a few months. It's fair if he doesn't answer immediately".Quote:
Originally Posted by Bi-honar
Come on bro, every professional coach's contract can be cancelled at any time after a few poor/disastrous performances. So no one should be planning more than a couple of days ahead of time?!Quote:
Originally Posted by xerexes
And the part about the negotiations are not true at all. The WC ended on July 16th, by July 19th and as soon as CQ returned from vacation in Brazil, IFF gave him a contract to sign. He didn't agree with the terms and instead of quickly negotiating something, he took off to Portugal on vacation and presumably to line up other contracts as multiple rumors surfaced. What followed was an unprofessional shit show that Kaffashian and CQ were equally to blame for.
Planning for a tournament you're contracted for while knowing you can be fired for bad results is normal. That's way different than planning for a tournament taking place after your contract is set to expire. I don't think there is a coach in the world who would plan for events beyond his contract or even be expected to.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bi-honar
Kaffashian himself admitted that IFF had given CQ the run around for months. Why would he admit to something that makes himself look bad if it isn't even true?Quote:
And the part about the negotiations are not true at all. The WC ended on July 16th, by July 19th and as soon as CQ returned from vacation in Brazil, IFF gave him a contract to sign. He didn't agree with the terms and instead of quickly negotiating something, he took off to Portugal on vacation and presumably to line up other contracts as multiple rumors surfaced. What followed was an unprofessional shit show that Kaffashian and CQ were equally to blame for.
Why hasn't the list been announced yet?
I thought we moved passed this CQ debate already? Goudarzi didn't want CQ so they tried to block funds. Everyone else including CQ was held up by vezarate varzesh va javanan.
Was this not the case and hasn't the matter been settled?
Really? We definitely have the best squad in Asia?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bi-honar
I'm sorry but that's just not true, if you look at Japan's roster they have player for player they are stronger, why else would CQ use defensive tactics against these type of teams?
Japan vs Iran player for player:
Kawashima (one of the best keepers in Belgium for 2-3 years now) >>> Haghighi (recently established GK in Portugal and TM)
Yuto Nagatomo (fixed inter Milan wingback) Atuso Uchida (arguably schalke's best defender) >>> Montazeri, Beikzadeh, Heydari
Kieuske Honda (fixed AC Milan stud) >>>>> Dejagah, Jahanbakhsh, Hajsafi
Makoto Hasebe (former Wolfsburg fix midfielder) <<<< Nekounam, Teymourian
Shinji Okazaki (4th leading goal scorer in the bundesliga) >>>>> Reza
Shinji Kagawa (Dortmund stud) >>>>> Masoud
Maya Yoshida (south Hampton, starts sometimes or comes off the bench others) <<<< Azmoun
Gotoku Sakai (Stuttgart starter) >>>>> Sadeghi, Seyyed Jalal
......be reasonable please, can you legitimately argue this? Not to mention this japan team has equally as good as a coach as us and also a FAR better preparation!
Now here's a different question: do I think TM is capable of beating japan if we run into the,? Sure I do. But again, the question at hand is who has the better squad and it most definitely is not us, that's reality but whether or not you chose to accept it is your call my friend!
Seyed jalal is the best defender in asia and kagawa has been shit for relegation dortmund but overall yes japan has the best squad