Kicker Rates from Bundesliga Round 14

[Essi]

Hamburger SV

Wächter (3) - Benjamin (4), B. Reinhardt (4,5), Mathijsen (3,5), Atouba (5) - Wicky (4), van der Vaart (3) - Mahdavikia (3), Trochowski (5) - Sanogo (4), Guerrero (5,5)

Trainer: Doll


Bayern München

Kahn (3) - Sagnol (5), Demichelis (5), van Buyten (3), Lahm (4) - Ottl (4,5) - van Bommel (4), Salihamidzic (4) - Schweinsteiger (4) - Makaay (2,5), Pizarro (3)

Trainer: Magath

Karimi did not play

http://www.kicker.de/fussball/bundesliga/spieltag/spielpaarungsbericht/object/763433

Hannover96

Enke (3) - Cherundolo (4), Zuraw (3,5), Vinicius (3,5), Tarnat (3) - Yankov (4) - Balitsch (4) - Stajner (4,5), Bruggink (4), Huszti (5) - Hashemian (4)

http://www.kicker.de/fussball/bundesliga/spieltag/spielpaarungsbericht/object/763438


Hertha BSC

Fiedler (3) - A. Friedrich (3), van Burik (4), Simunic (3), Fathi (3) - A. Schmidt (4) - K. Boateng (4), Dejagah (2,5), Gilberto (3) - Lakic (4), Pantelic (3)

Dejagah was selected as MVP.

Trainer: Götz
http://www.kicker.de/fussball/bundesliga/spieltag/spielpaarungsbericht/object/763436

[persianallstars]

thx for the info, well quite nice rates

[Martin-Reza]

They just don't like Hashemian...

Good for Mehdi

[Hadi]

4 is nice? you gotta be kidding.

[Essi]

They don't like Iranians.

[IRAN_TILL_I_DIE]

Hashemian got d winning goal...surely he deserves somtin beta than a 4

[Kamran]

nekounam got a 3 from kicker

[MissHannover]

Well yeah Hash scored the winning goal but during the game he could have been better ...:cool:

[ardi11]

They don't like Iranians.
i second that

[PersianMadrid7]

Karimi should quit sitting on the bench and go to the EPL. there are a couple of rich clubs that need a descent midfielder.

[Masoud_A]

^^I heard Murinhio wants him!

[ParsaV]

^^I heard Murinhio wants him!

ahahah LOL!

[persianallstars]

Well yeah Hash scored the winning goal but during the game he could have been better ...:cool:

therefore 4 is justified and quite well, there were days, Hash scored and he was rated with a 5. :nono:

[persianallstars]

4 is nice? you gotta be kidding.

regarding Mahdavikia and Dejaghah rates its nice, Hashemian has played below average therefore 4 is justified.

[KasraKhan]

Good grade for Mehdi

[Dariushm]

wtf how do you get a 4 after scoring the wining goal:furious:

[soniq]

i gave up on kicker grades a long time ago

[Dubxl152]

i gave up on kicker grades a long time ago

Likewise. Kicker bases its ratings on the opinion of 2 of their attending writers. There is no actual analysis, they decide the rating over a cup of coffee.